What I’ve Learned from Reviewing Children’s Books
http://school.discoveryeducation.com
Every time I receive a stack of children’s books in the mail to review, I really get excited. Unlike most adult books, kids’ books are colorful and playful and really stir creativity in the reader. I thoroughly enjoy the process of taking the time to read each book, examine the illustrations and determine the message the writer intended to get across to the reader. Here’s what I’ve learned:
- Books are way more sophisticated than they used to be. Many writers have figured out that children do not want to be patronized and can understand more than experts once thought. Science book for kids, in particular, are incredibly advanced these days, and enlighten parents as much as they teach children.
- A picture book with a good story but without great, vibrant illustrations is unappealing.
- A picture book with spectacular illustrations and an uninteresting or poorly written story is unappealing.
- Poor quality printing or binding makes a book a loser no matter how great the story or how great the illustrations may be.
- Muted colors in illustrations do not appeal to children (or to me).
- If I have to read a sentence over more than twice, it is not a well-written sentence.
- A good story is one that flows from page to page.
- A book that is not interesting to a parent will not be interesting to a child.
- Humor in writing or in illustrating is a very good thing.
- What a reviewer is looking for in a children’s book is a unique angle, a remarkable lesson, an informative message or just pure fun and adorableness.
- A story topic does not have to be new to be good; it just has to be presented in a unique way.
- Some story topics are way overdone. (i.e. being different, wanting to belong, stereotyped children, fluffy animals, etc)
- Some self-published books are very professionally done through and through.
- Some self-published books are riddled with errors, poor grammar, have shoddy printing or weak binding or all of the above.
- Just because a book is traditionally published does not mean it is excellent. In fact, some traditionally published books are very mediocre.
- A book that may excite one reader, may not excite another, but that doesn’t mean it is a bad book. Everyone has different tastes. In fact no matter how popular a book may be or how many have been sold, there is always going to be a critic who does not like it.
- Just because a book does not get a review does not mean it is a bad book. Thousands of books are published every day, and no review source can physically get to every book sent its way.
Click here to read some of my reviews and other great kids’ book reviews on the Good Reads with Ronna blog on LA Parent Magazine Online.





